What is the decision?
An impact study is useful only when it answers a defined question: whether to invest, how to compare alternatives, or how to evaluate a policy. Start with the decision and the counterfactual—what would happen without the proposed intervention.
What is the baseline?
The baseline should reflect a plausible path without the project or policy. Comparing a project with a zero-activity scenario can overstate benefits when economic activity would have occurred anyway.
Which effects are included?
Direct effects arise from the activity itself. Indirect effects may occur along supply chains; induced effects can follow changes in household spending. These categories must be defined carefully to avoid double counting.
How robust are the assumptions?
Employment, output and income estimates depend on data, model structure and assumptions about capacity, displacement and local sourcing. Results should be presented alongside uncertainty and limitations.
Can the findings support a decision?
The most useful output is not a large headline number. It is a transparent comparison of alternatives, the drivers of results, the main risks and the conditions under which conclusions might change.